Gamereactor International English / Dansk / Svenska / Norsk / Suomi / Deutsch / Italiano / Español
Log in member
amigo






Forgot password?
I'm not a member, but I want to be

Or log in with a Facebook account
FacebookFacebook
Review

Football Manager 2012

Text: Bengt Lemne

We've spent our first 35 hours or so with Football Manager 2012 and we've reconnected with a drug we don't mind being addicted to.

Once an addict, always an addict. It's as true for video games as it is for substance abuse and the Championship Manager/Football Manager has long been an addiction of mine. Although I haven't played it that much the last few years, it's one few games that can just wrap me up in a bobble and make me forget about food, sleep, friends and well, most everything.

What strikes me as a boot up Football Manager 2012 is just how massive a game this has become over the course of the last five years or so. 51 countries to choose from, massive amounts of competitions, players, managers, agents, physios and referees. The experience has also improved a lot, no longer is the game messy and unfinished at launch - it comes across as a polished and well crafted experience from day one. Good job, Sports Interactive.

And adding 800 new features and tweaks is an impressive number, but this year is no revolution. While there are many tweaks that will delight fans, they mainly patch up issues that were there with previous games and still there are some issues that are still there. One of the problems with such a huge game as Football Manager 2012 is the fact that it is huge - there is no way around it - even if Sports Interactive have tried to rework the interface and menus in order to make the whole game more accessible. Customisation options makes it a more tailored game, and playing on high resolution will allow you to fit a lot of information into just one screen - saving you a lot of time in the long run.

That said I played the game on my old, slightly crappy laptop. The very same laptop I played the last two games on, and I'm surprised at how fast games are processed and how smooth it runs. The option of adding and removing leagues at the start of each season is a massive improvement for those of us who play on underpowered computers and still wants to be able to have a career spanning various nations and challenges.

I'm the kind of player who loves to build clubs up - and this time I opted to manage Crewe Alexandra in League 2 - decent financials and a good youth set up (for the division) where my main motivation. Over the years I've managed so many of these lower league clubs, that it's starting to blend together. There is always to option of injecting steroids - i.e. loaning quality players from better clubs - but that's not really going to build the club moving forward. I went for a mix of old, new and borrowed - and the results were okay. I'm still working on making Crewe Alexandra a success, and I like the fact that it is a challenge.

The new way in which new youth team players are generated is nice, and towards the end of the first season my good youth system came through adding a 16 year-old who walked straight into the first team.

It's an interesting time for football with new UEFA regulations coming in to play. That may not be very relevant to Crewe Alexandra, but I'm sure a lot of would be managers would relish the opportunity of managing say Manchester City (just sell Tevez in time, before he starts making a fool of himself, or work hard keeping him happy). But making sure your youth team and academy produces talents is going to be key to longterm success in FM2012.

There are many other little improvements - match preparations and the ability to train several tactics, improved scouting, player negotiations and the addition of tone when communicating with players. The tone is a good way of calibrating when you really want to have an effect, and when you're just looking to have things the way they are. It adds to the role playing component of the game, but also adds another layer to the micro management of communications, and players who feel that this is a bit of a chore may not like the new options. Communication is problematic in the game, and press conferences remain a weakness of the game. Having to answer three questions about the form of one player after a poor performance is just not a lot of fun - and it feels like an area where you only really have things to lose and seldom much to gain. Of course, handing it off to the assistant is an alternative, but if you're stuck with a poor assistant manager in a lower league you may not want to do that.

Contract negotiations have been improved thanks to the ability of locking down certain variables - if you want the player to sign a longterm contract you can lock that option and ask his agent to come up with the rest of the terms to try and reach an agreement. It's a better way of quickly reaching a common ground in negotiations and it saves time. There are still some areas in contract negotiations that needs improvement - when I locked down the player wage to a level I could afford one agent came back with clauses that would double the wage after 30 games - something I just couldn't agree to and I wasn't able to lock that out of the negotiation (he came back with the same demands). Finally negotiations broke down.

I haven't mentioned the 3D match engine much, and that's cause I hardly use it. I stick with 2D matches and text commentary for the most part. It's what I accustomed to. The 3D matches still have some ways to go, before I would consider it entertainment to watch them, but it's getting better.

Even if Football Manager 2012 is an improved experience and the best Football Manager I've played I feel the need to deduct a point for the lack of any real game changing features. The developer has noted that a lot of players opt out of buying the game every year, and even if this is an improvement upon Football Manager 2011 - you shouldn't feel too bad about opting out of FM2012. That said, it's still an excellent game of football management with little or no competition.

Play movie

Football Manager 2012Football Manager 2012Football Manager 2012Football Manager 2012
Football Manager 2012Football Manager 2012Football Manager 2012Football Manager 2012
Football Manager 2012Football Manager 2012Football Manager 2012Football Manager 2012
Football Manager 2012Football Manager 2012Football Manager 2012Football Manager 2012
Related links:
Comment on text

You must be logged in to comment. If you are not yet a member - join now!

:D :) :( :-o :shock: :? 8) :lol: :x :P :oops: :cry: :evil: :twisted: :roll: ;-) :idea: :arrow: :| :mrgreen: :clap: :dance: #-o =; :^o [-X :pray: 8-[ :sick: :-# [-( :-k :--


Would you like to post this action to Facebook ?
Graphics:6
Gameplay:9
Sound:2
Lasting appeal:10
Our score:8/10
Plus:
Lots of little additional features, locks in negotiations, adding/removing leagues, monstrous database and a massive game.
Minus:
Not any game changing new features, menus are still a bit hard to navigate.
Game info
Football Manager 2012
Your collection
Similar games

The 20 latest programs:
(Interviews, reportages, reviews)

Toki Tori 2 - Two Tribes iDÉAME interview
2013-05-22

Co-founder and programmer Martijn Reuvers explains Toki Tori 2 simple but challenging concept, Wii U upcoming level editor and Steam plans in a sunny ..

GDC: Godsrule: War of Mortals - Interview
2013-05-22

We caught up with a couple of Gogogic founders, Gudmundur Björgmundsson and Jónas Antonsson, in a secret room during GDC to discuss browser game Godsr..

PAX: Call of Juarez: Gunslinger - Interview
2013-05-22

Call of Juarez is going digital with Gunslinger and we caught up with brand manager Aymeric Evennou to learn more.

Call of Duty: Ghosts - Lead Animator Interview
2013-05-22

We sat down with lead animator Zach Volker in L.A. to discuss the recently announced Call of Duty: Ghosts.

Watch Dogs - Lead Game Designer Interview
2013-05-21

Gamereactor’s Matti Isotalo was in Paris to talk to Ubisoft Montreal’s Danny Belanger about the hugely anticipated open-world adventure, Watch Dogs.

Jacob Jones and the Bigfoot Mystery - Gameplay
2013-05-21

We filmed the first few minutes of gameplay of this cute Vita game.

GDC: Magicka: Wizard Wars - Interview
2013-05-21

John Hargelid and David Nisshagen from Paradox North, a new development team, talks about their first project - a PvP focused Magicka title called Mag..

Turbo Super Stunt Squad - Global Gamer's Day Interview
2013-05-21

We caught up with Dreamworks' Andrea Frechette and senior producer of the game Brian Etheridge to discuss Turbo Super Stunt Squad - the film and the v..

PAX: Edge of Space - Interview
2013-05-21

We caught up with Handyman Studios' Jack Crane to discuss the upcoming indie title Edge of Space. He talks about influences from various games includi..

GDC: Dreamfall Chapters - Interview Dag Scheve & Martin Bruusgaard
2013-05-18

We caught up with Red Thread Games' Dag Scheve (writer) and Martin Bruusgaard (lead designer) to discuss the recently kickstarted Dreamfall Chapters.

Call of Duty Championships Special - Celebrities
2013-05-17

Are the top COD players turning into superstars? We asked the players at the Call of Duty Championships in Hollywood.

Spin the Bottle: Bumpie's Party - iDÉAME interview & live demo
2013-05-17

KnapNok Games' Lau and Dajana share their vision about motion controls and no-TV games. They also define their imminent Wii U party game Spin the Bott..

GDC: Anomaly 2 - Interview
2013-05-17

We had a chat with 11 Bit Studios' senior writer Pawel Miechowski about the recently released tower offense game Anomaly 2.

Press Start: Sanctum 2
2013-05-17

We captured just under half an hour of the early action in tower defence/first person shooter Sanctum 2 for your viewing pleasure. Enjoy!

GDC: Wargaming - Victor Kislyi Interview
2013-05-16

We sat down with Wargaming.net CEO Victor Kislyi in a boardroom of sorts to discuss their global expansion - the additions of new studios Gas Powered ..

GDC: Big Bite Soccer - Interview
2013-05-16

It's not every day we cover a Facebook game on GRTV, but Big Bite Soccer is a little different - and it should appeal to fans of classic football offe..

GDC: Nvidia Shield - Interview
2013-05-16

Jason Paul, director of product marketing at Nvidia, gives us a brief overview of the lay of the land with the upcoming Shield handheld, that offers a..

PAX: Wildstar - Mike Donatelli Interview
2013-05-15

We caught up with content director Mike Donatelli on the PAX East showfloor to learn more about the intriguing new MMORPG Wildstar.

Trailershow - 15 May
2013-05-15

Are you ready for the Trailershow?!

PAX: Dungeon Defenders II - Interview
2013-05-15

Trendy Entertainment's Josh Isom talks to us about the new competitive mode in Dungeon Defenders II (or MOBA mode if you will), as well as some of the..

GDC: Age of Wulin - Interview
2013-05-15

We took a limo ride with Gala Networks' Claas Wollter in order to find out more about some of the more unique features of Age of Wulin - a free-to-pla..

GRTV: Indiepub - Interview
2013-05-15

Gillen McAllister meet Indie Pub content manager and resident turkey impersonator PJ Hruschak at the Namco Bandai Global Gamers Day where Indie Pub pr..

PAX: Sanctum 2 - Lead Designer Interview
2013-05-15

We caught up with Sanctum 2 lead designer Oscar Jilsén at PAX East to discuss the sequel to the innovative tower defence slash first person shooter.

Full Mojo Rampage - interview and exclusive gameplay demo
2013-05-14

We sneak into Over the Top Games office to get an exclusive first look at Full Mojo Rampage, their first action-RPG. Meet its gameplay mechanics, arts..

RuneScape 3 - Design Director Interview
2013-05-14

We caught up with Jagex design director Mark Ogilvie to learn more about the direction the popular free-to-play MMORPG is taking next.

Cloudberry Kingdom - Pwnee Studios iDÉAME interview
2013-05-14

Co-founder & programmer Jordan Fisher talks us through one of the most difficult platformers we've got to play. The maths-lover explains how difficult..

Press Start: Metro: Last Light
2013-05-14

Watch us play the Metro: Last Light on Xbox 360 from the beginning up until just under the hour mark.

PAX: Luftrausers - Interview
2013-05-14

We caught up with Vlambeer's Rami Ismail at PAX East and learned more about the indie developer's 2D dogfighter Luftrausers.

Watch Dogs - Cinematic Lead Interview
2013-05-13

We caught up with cinematic lead Lars Bonde at a preview event for Watch Dogs to learn more about his contribution to the development process and what..

GDC: Expeditions: Conquistador Interview
2013-05-13

We caught up with creative director Jonas Waever from Logic Artists to discuss the novel turn-based strategy RPG Expeditions: Conquistador.

The Bureau: Xcom Declassified - Senior Producer Interview
2013-05-13

Mike Holmes caught up with senior producer Nico Bihary to discuss the prospects of tactical third person shooter The Bureau: Xcom Declassified and how..

Call of Duty Championships Special - Getting into COD
2013-05-10

In this second episode we talk to the players at the Call of Duty Championships about how they got into Call of Duty.

Runner 2 - Alex Neuse iDÉAME interview
2013-05-10

With Runner 2 already running on many platforms, Gaijin Games' co-founder announces future DLC and talks about reception and making great sequels. Bes..

Young Justice: Legacy - Interview
2013-05-09

Doug Panter, director of marketing at Little Orbit, talks us through their video game adaptation of Young Justice.

GDC: The Drowning - Interview
2013-05-08

Ben Cousins' career spans companies ranging from Lionhead to Sony and DICE, but his next project is DeNA owned Scattered Entertainment that's attempti..

Games To Look For: May
2013-05-08

We take a look at some of the bigger releases due in the month of May including Metro: Last Light, Fuse and Grid 2.

GDC: Ubisoft - Yannis Mallat Interview
2013-05-08

We had the chance to catch up with Ubisoft Montreal and Toronto Chief Executive Officer Yannis Mallat to talk about industry trends during GDC.

PAX: Neverwinter - Jack Emmert Interview
2013-05-08

Cryptic Studios CEO Jack Emmert talked to us about the next MMORPG coming out of the studio - Neverwinter - how it came to be, the state of the MMO sc..

GDC: Infinite Crisis - Executive Producer Interview
2013-05-07

We talked to Turbine's Jeffrey Steefel about their upcoming super hero MOBA - Infinite Crisis - a game that pits various multiverse editions of your f..

GDC: Cloudbuilt - Interview
2013-05-07

We caught up with Johannes Smidelöv from Swedish startup Coilworks to discuss their promising speed run-centric platformer Cloudbuilt.

Poll Do you want to see more DLC and online game-based content on the site?
  • 47% Yes - all and everything!
  • 20% Only for the bigger, current games
  • 33% Stick to retail/full digital releases, please.
Result
BETA +