Review

Gran Turismo 5

Text: Petter Hegevall (Gamereactor Sweden)

  1. PAGE:
  2. 1
  3. 2

After five years and eight months, Gamereactor's racing oracle Petter Hegevall has played and set a grade on Gran Turismo 5. Game of the year or a disappointment? Read our long review to find the answer!

What a wait it's been.

Five years and eight months have passed since the racing-crazy head-honcho of Polyphony, Kazunori Yamauchi, stood center stage during Sony's PS3 press conference in Los Angeles and talked about the most ambitious entry into the Gran Turismo series ever. But time went on. Gran Turismo HD became a demo; grey, pale, boring, despite its beautiful graphics. One year went by and we got Gran Turismo 5: Prologue. A handful of cars and a few levels for a cheap price, and it felt much better than Gran Turismo HD. It felt worth the money, and polished.

Gran Turismo 5 was supposed to be released a few months later - this time last year in fact. But time went by. No Gran Turismo 5. Until now.

Gran Turismo 5

While I wasn't a huge fan of Gran Turismo 4, since I thought there was a huge difference between Yamauchi's ambitious vision and the end result, my expectations for Gran Turismo 5 were still high. After more than 30 hours with it, I'm disappointed. This is not a bad game, but at the same time not nearly as good as I would have hoped.

When Gran Turismo 5 is good, it's fantastic. It shines like a carefully polished diamond with fantastic graphics and balanced car physics. When Gran Turismo 5 is bad, it's really bad. Sloppy graphics, stuttering frame rate, hopelessly repetitive and a weak presentation. It doesn't take long before it becomes obvious that the development of Polyphony's fifth game in the series hasn't only been expensive, it's also been problematic. The game feels inconsistent, and the general experience fragmented - either way, it's high quality racing as long as you stay away from the worst pitfalls.

It's taken Polyphony more than five years to finish development on Gran Turismo 5. It has cost the developer millions and millions of dollars. Which is a lot of money and time for a game which damage modelling and online modes that still can't compete with racing giants like Forza Motorsport 3 or Need for Speed: Shift. Instead it's the amount of cars and racing cups in the game's career mode that makes up the basis of Gran Turismo 5. This is where Polyphony spent most of its energy. 1031 different cars and more than 60 races is a rather solid foundation to park an overloaded racing car on. And it would have been even more solid if it wasn't for the fact that Polyphony had stressed out some parts while they've shaped others with extreme care.

Gran Turismo 5

But to feel that realism, there's a price. You simply can't feel the small improved differences with a standard Dual shock 3 controller. With myself parked in Gamereactor's Fanatec Rennsport-cockpit with a Logitech G27 steering wheel in my hands and with the gas pedal pressed down on the game's Calsonic Nissan GT-R, Gran Turismo 5 is fantastic. The car physics in the Gran Turismo series have always been a bit stiff since the start. It's been too mechanical, too heavy. In Gran Turismo 4 it often felt like you were driving a 12,000 kilo heavy lump of steel and not a 1200 kilo light Japan GT-monster. In Gran Turismo 5, Polyphony have been working hard with the tire physics and how the weight is distributed, which you can really feel. There's another kind of dynamic in how the car tires react when you turn a tight corner. It's more exact than ever before, with an added sense of speed and power. With my chosen car, on my chosen track, and without any stupid droner cars controlled by the game's AI, I throw myself on to the tracks of Laguna Seca, Monza and Suzuka to improve my lap times.

And that's when Gran Turismo 5 truly shines of pure quality. With the G27 everything is changed. That Polyphony this time around simulates the air pressure in the tires and the heat of that air up to 180 times per minute is noticeable. I get a more detailed form of feedback from my steering wheel and I feel faster than ever round Laguna Seca in a Gran Turismo car.

Gran Turismo 5

A few hours later put myself into Sebastien Loeb's WRC-car the contrast is almost overwhelming. The mix between the brilliant feel and micro millimeter-precise tire physics to hopelessly slippery make the bad car physics almost feel like a parody at times. The same goes for the Kart-racing, which like the WRC events, should have been taken out. The karts are fast and very responsive, just like in reality, but at the same time they feel more like arcade-karts with their silky smooth stability. And the problems don't end there.

Gran Turismo 5's presentation is more or less worthless. Several different graphical styles are mixed into a huge mess of bad typography and badly designed menus. You have to jump around through the menu system like a madman during the career mode and everything is covered in bad elevator jazz. The menus are meant to mimic some form of exclusive computer program, but it only manages to annoy. Example: the fact that you have to click nine times to pick out and test-drive the cars you win in the game's various races is one of the oddest design choices this year.

Gran Turismo 5
  1. PAGE:
  2. 1
  3. 2
The text continues on the next page
Gran Turismo 5Gran Turismo 5Gran Turismo 5Gran Turismo 5
Gran Turismo 5Gran Turismo 5Gran Turismo 5Gran Turismo 5
Gran Turismo 5Gran Turismo 5Gran Turismo 5Gran Turismo 5
Gran Turismo 5Gran Turismo 5Gran Turismo 5Gran Turismo 5
Gran Turismo 5Gran Turismo 5Gran Turismo 5Gran Turismo 5
Related links:

The 20 latest programs:
(Interviews, reportages, reviews)

Diablo III - Launch Teaser
2012-05-16

We were on site for one of six official European Diablo III launch events in Stockholm. In this brief teaser you can see people go nuts as they count ..

Diablo III - Cinematics Interview
2012-05-16

We caught up with Noel Wolfman, production director at the Cinematics department at Blizzard, to discuss cinematics and the Diablo III launch.

Ubisoft Massive - Managing Director Interview
2012-05-16

At a recent visit to Ubisoft Massive, currently working on the multiplayer of Far Cry 3 and a big secret project, we caught up with managing director ..

Lollipop Chainsaw Special
2012-05-15

Did you miss out on an invitation to the Lollipop Chainsaw party during GDC? Fear not. We've got you covered. Starring Suda51, James Gunn and Juliet S..

FIFA 13 - Gameplay Director Interview
2012-05-15

We caught up with Aaron McHardy to talk about the new FIFA 13, and what Aaron calls "gameplay nuggets".

Review: Max Payne 3
2012-05-14

Max Payne is finally back and Rasmus sat down with Lee to tell us if Rockstar has done him justice.

GRTV News - 11 May
2012-05-11

Anastasiya brings us good news - Dead Space 3 announced - and bad news - Bioshock Infinite delayed - in this edition of GRTV News.

Games to look for in May
2012-05-10

May is a busy month for gaming as Max Payne 3 and Diablo III are finally hitting stores, but there are also other interesting titles to keep an eye on..

AR Drone 2.0 - First Impressions
2012-05-10

Thomas Blichfeldt has been climbing the rooftops testing the new iteration of the popular RC hovercraft AR Drone.

Far Cry 3 - Multiplayer Producer Interview
2012-05-10

We talked to Petter Sydow, multiplayer producer at Ubisoft Massive on Far Cry 3, about the development of the game and the co-operation with Ubisoft M..

Madagascar 3 - Interview
2012-05-10

We caught up with Brian Etheridge, senior producer on Madagascar 3: The Video Game, to learn more about the latest game based on an animated movie.

Manse Games - Interview
2012-05-09

Manse Games is a governmentally funded initiative that has helped the Tampere region in Finland develop into one of the world's richest regions for in..

Dreamtopia - Interview
2012-05-09

We caught up with Ngmoco's Catherine Silvestri to learn more about Dreamtopia and just what kind of dreams we can realise in that game.

Review: Prototype 2
2012-05-08

Thomas Blichfeldt sat down with Prototype 2 reviewer Lee West to find out more about the sequel and whether or not it lives up to expectations.

Anmynor - Interview
2012-05-08

When the developers had left GDC early, we were left to interview Derek Asoto about Anmynor, who works on Hero Engine that powers the game.

Trailershow - May 8th 2012
2012-05-08

Not sure which trailers are worth your time? Anastasiya has the solution.

A Game of Dwarves - Lead Designer Interview
2012-05-07

We caught up with lead designer to talk about Zeal Game Studios' A Game of Dwarves - a classical management game littered with short fellows who like..

Visions of Zosimos - Interview
2012-05-04

We met with Forever Interactive's Eldon Kurth to find out more about the novel MMO proposition of Visions of Zosimos.

Hegemony: Rome - Interview
2012-05-04

Hegemony Rome developers Longbow Games were one of the last developers we met up with at GDC as we try and find out more about their upcoming strategy..

Skyfall - Interview
2012-05-04

We caught up with Tom Hess, producer at Ngmoco on the recently released Android RPG Skyfall that is also making it's way onto iOS in the near future.

Starvoid - Interview
2012-05-03

Zeal Game Studios are working on a pick up and play real time strategy game called Starvoid (formerly known as Red Frontier) and we caught up with gam..

Shadow Puppeteer - Interview
2012-05-03

We caught up with Klas Lothe from Norwegian Sarepta Studio to talk about their interesting new project - Shadow Puppeteer.

Download Roundup: May 2012
2012-05-03

It's the debut of GRTV's all-new, all-digital monthly show: Download Roundup! The biggest names of the month reviewed and rated as we ask: which is wo..

Codemasters Racenet - Interview
2012-05-03

Gamereactor's Arttu Rajala caught up with Codemasters' Ian Smith to discuss the features of the recently announced and launched Racenet service.

EA Sports Executive Vice President Andrew Wilson - Interview
2012-05-02

The EA Sports VP talks social gaming, roster crossovers, the future of FIFA and much more.

The Repopulation - Interview
2012-05-01

Co-lead developer Josh Halls talks us through the plans for his studio's F2P MMO sandbox sci-fi spectacular, Repopulation.

Fractured Soul - Interview
2012-05-01

We talk to Endgame Studios about its dual-screen 3DS actioner in the style of Castlevania and Metroid.

N.O.V.A. 3 - First 10 min
2012-04-30

Here's the first ten minutes of N.O.V.A 3 on iPad 2, the returning FPS.

GRTV News - 27 April
2012-04-27

Anastasiya returns to give us a brief look at the top news stories of the week.

Disgaea 3: Abscence of Detention - Interview
2012-04-27

We caught up with Jack Niida and Ryan Phillips from NIS America to discuss the PS Vita version of Disgaea 3.

Soft Kinetic - Interview
2012-04-27

We met up with Virgile Delporte from Soft Kinetic to discuss their technology and the future of gesture based controls.

Dishonored - Creative Directors Interview
2012-04-27

Gillen met with creative directors Harvey Smith and Raphaël Colantonio to discuss the design decisions that have gone into creating the extremely prom..

Line of Defense - Interview
2012-04-26

"It's pretty much taking two scorpions and dropping them in a jar." 3000AD's Derek Smart explains his vision for game balance among other things in th..

Battlefield 3 - Close Quarters Interview
2012-04-26

DICE have plans for themed DLC packs for Battlefield 3. First up is Close Quarters, and we recently talked to lead designer Niklas Fegraeus about it.

Tera - Westernisation Interview
2012-04-26

We caught up with Frogster's Ellen-Jane Austin to discuss the "westernisation" of upcoming MMORPG Tera.

Bitsquid - Interview
2012-04-26

Bitsquid is an up and coming engine developer that is used for such games as War of the Roses, The Showdown Effect, and the upcoming Oddworld titles. ..

Colors! 3D - Interview
2012-04-26

We caught up with Jens Andersson, creator of the recently released Colors! 3D, during GDC and he told us all about what the Nintendo 3DS application i..

Crysis 3 - Interview
2012-04-24

Vegatation. Alien weapons. The Revenge tour. Crytek's Director of Creative Development Rasmus Højengaard talks Crysis 3.

War of the Roses - Hands-on Interview
2012-04-23

We were on site for the very first press hands-on session with War of the Roses to learn more about the mechanics and gruesome executions from lead de..

War Inc. - Interview
2012-04-23

We caught up with War Inc. producer Tyler Sparks at a hotel during GDC to find out more about the recently launched free-to-play shooter.

Poll Did Blizzard get a bad deal over DOTA naming rights?
  • 50% 1. Yes, the DotA was a Warcraft mod, Blizzard should have the rights.
  • 0% 2. No, Valve hired one of people responsible for the mod, the name should be theirs.
  • 0% 3. They should both take a seat on the naughty step.
  • 50% 4. Isn't it nice when two massive companies can settle a dispute in such a friendly manner.
Result
Gamereactor iPad Magazine
Gamereactor Gamereactor since 1998 - Published by Gamez Publishing A/S Toftebæksvej 6, 2800 Kongens Lyngby, Denmark +4545887600

Gamereactor.eu

Read the latest reviews, news, previews and much more from Gamereactor

Screenshots